Florida Panthers @ Toronto Maple Leafs Player Props, Picks and Predictions - 5/14/2025 7:00 PM EDT

We have your Florida Panthers @ Toronto Maple Leafs prop betting and game preview needs covered as the Toronto Maple Leafs hit the road to face the Florida Panthers.

Florida Panthers @ Toronto Maple Leafs Pick

Best Moneyline Odds: Florida Panthers -135, Toronto Maple Leafs +114.
Best Spread Odds: Florida Panthers -1.5 (+115), Toronto Maple Leafs +1.5 (-135).
Best Total Odds: Over 6.0 (-110), Under 6.0 (-110).

Game Info

Date: May 14, 2025
Time: 7:00 PM EDT
Location: FLA Live Arena, Sunrise, Florida
TV: -

Florida Panthers @ Toronto Maple Leafs Preview

The Florida Panthers and Toronto Maple Leafs face off in Game 5 of their second-round playoff series. The Panthers hold a commanding lead in the series, showcasing their dominance in special teams with an 87% penalty kill success rate, neutralizing 13 of Toronto's 15 power plays. Florida has been strong at home, while Toronto will need to dig deep to extend the series. Both teams have shown offensive firepower, making this a potentially high-scoring affair.

Historic Head-to-Head Stats and Analysis

In their last nine matchups, Florida has a 6-3 record against Toronto. The Panthers have also been dominant at home, winning five of their last six games in Sunrise. However, Toronto has managed to keep games close, often covering the spread as underdogs. The total has gone OVER in five of Florida's last six home games, indicating a trend toward high-scoring contests when these teams meet.

Pick: Florida Panthers Moneyline (-135)

widget-odds-nhl-su-5753-FLA-TOR

The Panthers have been the better team throughout the series, leveraging their home-ice advantage and excelling in special teams. With Toronto struggling to capitalize on power-play opportunities and Florida's strong penalty kill, the Panthers are well-positioned to close out the series. Betting on Florida's moneyline at -135 offers solid value given their recent dominance.

Top Player Prop Picks

1. Aleksander Barkov Over 0.5 Assists (-)

widget-props-nhl-5753-2343528

Barkov has been a key playmaker for the Panthers, consistently setting up scoring opportunities. With Florida's offense firing on all cylinders, expect Barkov to record at least one assist in this game.

2. Auston Matthews Over 3.5 Shots on Goal (-)

widget-props-nhl-5753-2343470

Matthews has been Toronto's offensive leader, and with the Maple Leafs facing elimination, he will likely be aggressive in generating scoring chances. Look for him to surpass 3.5 shots on goal.

3. Matthew Tkachuk Anytime Goal Scorer (-)

Tkachuk has been a force for the Panthers, scoring crucial goals throughout the series. With Florida looking to close out the series at home, Tkachuk is a strong candidate to find the back of the net.