Tennessee Titans at Indianapolis Colts Player Props, Picks and Predictions - 12/22/2024 1:00 PM EST

We have your Tennessee Titans at Indianapolis Colts prop betting and game preview needs covered as the Tennessee Titans hit the road to face the Indianapolis Colts.

Tennessee Titans at Indianapolis Colts Odds Info

Best Moneyline Odds: Tennessee Titans +160 (ESPN BET) / Indianapolis Colts -190 (BetMGM)
Best Spread Odds: -3.5 - Tennessee Titans -110 (BetMGM) / Indianapolis Colts -108 (DraftKings)
Best Total Odds: 42.5 - Under -110 (BetMGM) / Over -110 (BetMGM)

Game Info

Date: 12/22/2024
Time: 1:00 PM EST
Location: Lucas Oil Stadium (Indianapolis, IN)
TV: CBS

Historic Head-to-Head Stats and Analysis

Over the past two seasons, the Indianapolis Colts and Tennessee Titans have faced each other three times, with the Colts emerging victorious in all three encounters. The games were played between October 2023 and October 2024. In these matchups, the visiting team won twice, while the home team secured a single victory. The Colts consistently covered the spread in all three games, while the Titans failed to do so. The total score went over the set line once and stayed under twice. These games have shown a pattern of the Colts outperforming the Titans, both in terms of outright victories and against the spread.

The most recent game took place on October 13, 2024, where the Indianapolis Colts defeated the Tennessee Titans with a final score of 20-17. The Colts were the visiting team and managed to cover the spread, which closed at -2.5 in their favor. Joe Flacco led the Colts' offense with two touchdown passes, one to Josh Downs and another to Michael Pittman Jr. The Titans responded with a touchdown pass from Will Levis to Nick Westbrook-Ikhine and a rushing touchdown by Tony Pollard. The Colts recorded 269 total yards and 20 first downs, while the Titans had 241 total yards and 16 first downs. Both teams had one turnover each, with Flacco and Levis throwing one interception apiece. The game ended with a total score of 37, which was under the closing over-under line of 41.5.

In the December 3, 2023, matchup, the Colts again emerged victorious, defeating the Titans 31-28 in an overtime thriller. The Colts, as the visiting team, covered the spread, which closed at 1.5 in their favor. The game saw a high total score of 59, going over the set line of 42.5. The Colts' offense was led by a strong passing game, with 312 passing yards and two touchdowns. The Titans, despite a solid rushing performance with 177 yards and two touchdowns, could not secure the win. In the October 8, 2023, game, the Colts won 23-16 at home, covering the spread as favorites. The total score of 39 was under the closing line of 43.5. The Colts' balanced attack and strong defense were key in securing the victory.

Tennessee Titans at Indianapolis Colts Preview

The Tennessee Titans are set to face the Indianapolis Colts in a Week 16 matchup that carries significant implications for both teams. The Titans, currently struggling with a 3-11 record, are in the midst of a challenging season marked by inconsistency and a recent quarterback controversy. Head coach Brian Callahan has decided to bench Will Levis, who has been plagued by turnovers, including 12 interceptions this season, tied for the fourth most in the NFL. Mason Rudolph is expected to start in his place, bringing a slightly steadier hand, having completed 63 percent of his passes for 1,015 yards, six touchdowns, and five interceptions in limited action this season.

On the other side, the Indianapolis Colts, with a 6-8 record, are clinging to slim playoff hopes. Despite a recent loss to the Denver Broncos, the Colts remain in the hunt, albeit needing help from other teams to secure a postseason berth. The Colts' offense, led by Anthony Richardson, has shown flashes of potential but has been inconsistent, particularly in the passing game. Richardson has struggled with accuracy, posting the league's worst completion percentage, and has been prone to turnovers, much like his counterpart Levis.

Historically, the Colts have had the upper hand in this rivalry, winning the last three encounters against the Titans. The Colts' defense has been opportunistic, capitalizing on opponents' mistakes, which could be a critical factor against a turnover-prone Titans team. The Titans' offense, despite featuring playmakers like Calvin Ridley, has been unable to find a consistent rhythm, ranking 27th in points per game.

As the Titans travel to Lucas Oil Stadium, they face a Colts team that is favored to win, with oddsmakers setting the line in favor of Indianapolis. The Colts' ability to exploit the Titans' vulnerabilities, particularly in the passing game, will be crucial. Meanwhile, the Titans will look to Mason Rudolph to provide a spark and potentially salvage some pride in a season that has not gone according to plan.

Tennessee Titans at Indianapolis Colts Pick: Indianapolis Colts Moneyline

The Indianapolis Colts are poised to capitalize on their recent dominance over the Tennessee Titans, making them a strong pick for the moneyline in this Week 16 matchup. Historically, the Colts have had the upper hand, winning the last three encounters against the Titans, including a 20-17 victory earlier this season. This trend of success is bolstered by the Colts' ability to cover the spread consistently in these matchups, showcasing their capacity to outperform the Titans both outright and against the spread.

Heading into this game, the Colts are favored, and for good reason. Despite their 6-8 record, they remain in the playoff hunt, driven by a sense of urgency to keep their postseason hopes alive. The Colts' defense has been particularly opportunistic, a critical factor when facing a turnover-prone Titans team. Will Levis, the Titans' quarterback, has struggled significantly with ball security, throwing 12 interceptions this season, which is tied for the fourth most in the NFL. His recent benching in favor of Mason Rudolph underscores the instability at the quarterback position for Tennessee.

In contrast, the Colts, led by Anthony Richardson, have shown flashes of potential, particularly in their passing game, despite some inconsistencies. Richardson's ability to exploit the Titans' defensive vulnerabilities could be pivotal. Moreover, the Colts' defense has demonstrated a knack for capitalizing on opponents' mistakes, which could spell trouble for a Titans offense that ranks 27th in points per game and has struggled to find a consistent rhythm.

With the game set at Lucas Oil Stadium, the Colts have the home-field advantage, further tipping the scales in their favor. The oddsmakers have set the line in favor of Indianapolis, reflecting the broader sentiment that the Colts are well-positioned to secure a victory. Given the Titans' ongoing struggles and the Colts' recent track record against them, the Indianapolis Colts moneyline emerges as a compelling pick for this matchup.

Tennessee Titans at Indianapolis Colts Top Player Prop Picks

Mason Rudolph Over 209.5 Passing Yards - Passing Yards Prop -110 (BetMGM)

Mason Rudolph is set to start for the Tennessee Titans against the Indianapolis Colts, and his recent performance suggests he could surpass the 209.5 passing yards mark. In his last outing against the Cincinnati Bengals, Rudolph completed 21-of-26 passes for 209 yards, demonstrating efficiency and the ability to move the ball through the air. With the Titans' offense struggling to find consistency, Rudolph's arm will be crucial in keeping them competitive. The Colts' defense, while opportunistic, has shown vulnerabilities, particularly in the passing game, which Rudolph can exploit. Given the Titans' need to rely on their passing attack, especially with their season effectively over, Rudolph is likely to have ample opportunities to air it out, making the over on this prop a compelling choice.

Anthony Richardson Under 58.5% Completion Rate - Completion Percentage Prop -110 (DraftKings)

Anthony Richardson has struggled with accuracy throughout the season, posting the league's worst completion percentage. His issues in turning dropbacks into completions have been well-documented, and against a Titans defense that will be looking to capitalize on any mistakes, Richardson's completion rate is likely to remain low. The Titans, despite their struggles, have a defense capable of applying pressure, which could further exacerbate Richardson's accuracy woes. With the Colts needing to push for a playoff spot, Richardson may be forced into high-risk throws, potentially lowering his completion percentage even further. Thus, the under on this completion rate prop is a strong play.

Calvin Ridley Over 69.5 Receiving Yards - Receiving Yards Prop -110 (FanDuel)

Calvin Ridley has been a bright spot in the Titans' offense, averaging nearly 15 yards per catch this season. With Mason Rudolph taking over at quarterback, Ridley is likely to be a primary target, especially given the Titans' need to establish a passing game to stay competitive. The Colts' defense, while effective at forcing turnovers, has allowed significant yardage through the air, which Ridley can exploit. His ability to stretch the field and make big plays will be crucial for the Titans, and with Rudolph's tendency to look for deep shots, Ridley is well-positioned to exceed the 69.5 receiving yards mark. This makes the over on his receiving yards prop an attractive option.