Welcome to Upset Watch

If you're new to Pickwatch, or have never read Upset Watch, here's what we do:

With over 35% of NFL games ending in an underdog outright win, it's important to know when upsets are most likely to occur, and which teams to pick.

Every Wednesday, we select a number of underdogs that have a statistically higher chance of winning than others. To do this, we use historical trends, such as the number of underdogs that win each week of the season, and we then use a weighted ranking of each team's current 'true' performance to assess how well they are playing, and whether the matchup is favorable to their strengths.

Why underdogs and not favorites?

Because underdog winners yield bigger profits from the greater odds you face, you don't need to win every pick you make, or even half of the picks that you make.

In 2021, betting $100 on every underdog winner that we picked would have yielded you a profit of+$3,200 over the course of the season. This year, we have made a profit to this point of over +$2,500.

Contents (click to jump to section - Pro subscription required for picks):

Last Week's Performance

How to use Upset Watch

Quick Picks

About Weighted Stats

Our weighted stats in the header for each game are different to the 'raw' stats you can find on other websites.

Weighted stats indicate the performance of a team against the averages of their opponents. For example, if a team scores 30 points against a team that gives up 29 points on average, their weighted performance will be +1. If they score 30 points against a team that gives up 20 points on average, their performance is +10, because they scored 10 points more than that opponent normally allows.

Over the course of a season, we can see the balance of the weighted performance as a 'true' measure of a team's real caliber. A team that ranks highly in a category generally has a good performance in this statistic regardless of how strong their opponents are.

*Note: As we head into the final weeks of the season, we are using weighted stats from the last 5 games for each team, giving a more accurate indication of where teams are now, given injuries, QB changes, coaches being fired, or late season good/bad form.

About the stats

We include several categories of weighted stats for offense and defense. These cover scoring, passing, rushing, and pass protection. On defense, we replace pass protection with pass rush, and turnovers are factored in on both sides of the ball.

By placing the units side-by-side with the unit they are up against (eg: Pass protection vs Pass rush) you can not only see where a team is strongest, but also whether the opposing unit is likely to be strong or weak too.

Last week's performance

Our 5th winning week in a row! That's a great result in the playoffs, where picking underdogs is much harder than during the regular season. Our new weighted score projections flagged up both the Giants and Jaguars as viable winners, and thanks to some heroics by Trevor Lawrence, both picks were on the money.

Altogether, discounting our Tampa Bay Dampa squib, we went 2-0 on money line picks and 0-1 on ATS picks, for a total profit of +$165, and a ROI of 55%!

Season Performance 

That profit from our weekly performance pushed us over the $2,500 mark for the first time in 2022. It's now safe to say that we'll finish heavily in profit for the second successive year, and we're now close to +$6,000 in profit over the last two years if you placed a $100 bet on every selection. Of course, that's purely illustrative, if you put a $10 bet on each pick, that'd be $600 in profit, and so forth.

On the season, our money line picks are +$1,395 (46.7%, 43-49-1) on the season. This far exceeds any performance among all NFL experts who have made over 85 NFL underdog picks this season, as you can see by viewing our Underdog metrics.

Our underdog cover picks are +$1,176 (71%, 22-9-2), which is also incredibly strong, and you can get a sense of how good this is by comparing with any expert who has made more than 10% of NFL ATS picks this season on our ATS pages.

How to use Upset Watch

I get asked this question a lot, about the best way to use the information in Upset Watch. For me, our $100 a pick metric serves to illustrate that the core picks are good, but there are ways to pick that are more complex and generate potentially bigger payouts.

I've transferred this section of Upset Watch to a separate article, as I attempt to make the weekly column easier to read, so if you want to see my tips for how to maximize profit alongside many thousands of other subscribers, check this link out.